Wishlist Guru vs Wishlist Hero at a glance

Both apps do the core job of a wishlist tool and both offer a free plan, so the differences are in the details. The figures below come from each app's Shopify App Store listing.

 Wishlist GuruWishlist Hero
DeveloperWebframezRevamp
Rating4.84.7
Reviews92385
Built for Shopify badgeYesNo badge shown on the listing
Free planYes — up to 300 wishlist items / monthYes — up to 500 wishlist additions / month
Paid plans start at$5.99 / month$4 / month
Listingapps.shopify.com/wishlist-guruapps.shopify.com/wishlist-hero

Ratings, review counts, features and pricing were checked in July 2026 and can change. Always confirm the current details on each app's live Shopify App Store listing before you decide.

Wishlist Guru: what the listing shows

Wishlist Guru: Favorites List is built by Webframez and, according to its Shopify App Store listing, holds a 4.8 rating from 92 reviews and carries the Built for Shopify badge. It offers a free plan capped at up to 300 wishlist items per month.

Listed key features include:

  • Easy 1-click setup and VIP support
  • Button customization and guest wishlist
  • Alerts for price drop, back in stock and low stock
  • Multi-wishlist and multi-variant support
  • Klaviyo integration and email reports
  • GDPR, multilingual UI/UX and email templates

Where it stands out: the higher rating (4.8) and the Built for Shopify badge may reassure merchants who want an app that meets Shopify's latest quality standards, and it names Klaviyo integration directly on the listing.

Worth weighing: its 92 reviews are a smaller sample than some rivals, so there's less public feedback to read through. Some capabilities discussed in third-party write-ups (such as Shopify Flow, B2B settings, REST APIs or a drawer mode) weren't confirmed word-for-word on the listing we loaded — check the current listing to confirm exactly what's included on each plan.

Paid pricing, per the listing: Free ($0); Basic $5.99/month or $59.99/year; Pro $12.99/month or $129.99/year; Premium $19.99/month or $199.99/year.

Wishlist Hero: what the listing shows

Wishlist Hero is built by Revamp and, according to its Shopify App Store listing, holds a 4.7 rating from 385 reviews. No Built for Shopify badge appears on its listing. It offers a free plan for up to 500 wishlist additions per month.

Listed key features include:

  • Code-free, one-click setup with seamless theme integration
  • Email reminders for low stock or price drops
  • Multiple currencies and languages with pixel tracking
  • Wishlist additions from product pages, collections and quick views
  • Share a wishlist via email and social media
  • Detailed reports

Where it stands out: with 385 reviews it has the deeper public track record of the two, plus explicit social and email sharing and the ability to add items from collections and quick views.

Worth weighing: its rating (4.7) sits just below Guru's, and there's no Built for Shopify badge on the listing. The listing doesn't clarify whether the 500-additions free limit resets each month or is a lifetime cap, so confirm that on the pricing box before committing.

Paid pricing, per the listing: Silver $4/month, Gold Plus $17/month, Platinum $29/month.

Pricing compared

On headline entry price, Wishlist Hero is lower — its Silver plan is $4/month versus Wishlist Guru's Basic at $5.99/month. Both apps also give you a free tier to start with, though the allowances differ: Guru's free plan covers up to 300 wishlist items per month, while Hero's covers up to 500 wishlist additions per month.

Higher up the range the plans diverge. Guru lists Pro at $12.99/month and Premium at $19.99/month (with discounted annual options), while Hero lists Gold Plus at $17/month and Platinum at $29/month. Because each plan bundles different limits and features, compare the specific tier you'd actually use rather than only the starting price — and check both listings for what each tier includes, since plan contents can change.

How WishList Ninja compares

(disclosure: WishList Ninja is our app.)

Wishlist Guru and Wishlist Hero are both solid, review-backed wishlist tools, and if a simple wishlist with stock and price alerts is all you need, either is a reasonable choice. WishList Ninja (apps.shopify.com/wishlist-ninja) is built for a different job: turning wishlist activity into email-marketing intent your ESP can act on.

Two things set it apart:

  • A live has_active_wishlist flag on every shopper's profile. WishList Ninja writes has_active_wishlist onto each shopper's Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend profile in real time — and it's true only while items are actually saved. It also syncs wishlist_count, wishlist_value and the top saved item, so you can segment and email only the shoppers who have live buying intent right now.
  • 7 automated flow triggers: Added to Wishlist, Price Drop, On Sale, Low Stock, Back in Stock, Collection Saved, and New in a Saved Collection — ready to power automations in your email platform.

Pricing runs $19–$249/month with a 30-day free trial and unlimited saves; there is no free plan (unlike both apps above). It installs in one click with no code and adds a roughly 12KB script. Honest caveat: WishList Ninja is brand-new in 2026, so it has few reviews so far — Wishlist Guru (92) and Wishlist Hero (385) both have longer public track records today. If deep ESP segmentation on live intent matters more to you than review count, it's worth a look; if you want the most-reviewed option, Hero currently leads.