Magic Wishlist vs Growave at a glance
Both apps are marked Built for Shopify and both offer a free plan, but they aim at different jobs. The table below reflects only what each app's Shopify App Store listing showed when checked in July 2026 — always confirm on the live listing before you decide.
| Magic Wishlist | Growave | |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Magic Apps | Growave |
| Built for Shopify | Yes | Yes |
| Rating (reviews) | 5.0 (10 reviews) | 4.8 (1,235 reviews) |
| Free plan | Yes — a single plan named “Free” | Yes — Free $0, 200 orders/month |
| Paid pricing | No paid tiers shown on the listing — check the listing | Entry $15/mo, Growth $199/mo, Plus $499/mo (scaling by monthly orders) |
| Main focus | Dedicated wishlist | Loyalty, wishlist, reviews & referrals suite |
In short: Magic Wishlist is the narrower, wishlist-only tool, while Growave bundles wishlist into a wider retention platform.
Magic Wishlist: a focused wishlist app
According to its Shopify App Store listing, Magic Wishlist is a dedicated wishlist app from Magic Apps that is Built for Shopify and rated 5.0 from 10 reviews.
What the listing highlights:
- Set up in about 1 minute, with no coding, on any Shopify theme.
- Guest wishlists — shoppers can save products with no account or login.
- Automatic emails when saved products drop in price or come back in stock.
- Auto-sent discount codes to bring wishlist shoppers back to buy.
- Shareable wishlists to help attract new buyers.
Its Free plan is listed as including unlimited wishlists; Back in Stock, Price Drop and Restock alerts; wishlist reminders and discounts; guest, share and multi-wishlist; integrations named as Klaviyo, GA4, Meta Ads, Yotpo, Mailchimp, Omnisend, n8n and make.com; Shopify Flow integration; and multi-language support.
Things to weigh: the listing shows only a single Free plan — no paid tiers are displayed — and it does not state a numeric usage limit (for example an item or subscriber cap). If you need to know how it scales for a large catalogue or list, check the current App Store listing for details. The review base is also small (10 reviews) compared with more established apps, which is normal for a focused newer tool but worth noting.
Growave: loyalty and wishlist in one suite
According to its Shopify App Store listing, Growave is a broader retention platform from Growave, Built for Shopify, and rated 4.8 from 1,235 reviews — a substantial review base.
What the listing highlights:
- Loyalty program with reward points
- Wishlist
- Product reviews
- Referrals and VIP tiers
- POS support and store-credit rewards
- Apple/Google Wallet integration
- Checkout extensions for Shopify Plus
- Multi-language support (16+ languages)
Pricing (per its listing): a Free plan at $0 for 200 orders/month (including loyalty points, wishlist and product reviews); Entry at $15/month (500 monthly orders, then $20 per 100 additional); Growth at $199/month (1,500 monthly orders, then $15 per 100 additional); and Plus at $499/month (3,000 monthly orders, then $10 per 100 additional).
Things to weigh: Growave is a fuller suite, so the wishlist is one feature among many — great if you want loyalty and reviews too, but potentially more than you need if you only want a wishlist. Pricing is tied to monthly order volume, and there is a notable step up between the Entry ($15) and Growth ($199) tiers, so map your order count to a plan before committing.
How WishList Ninja compares
(Disclosure: WishList Ninja is our app.) We built WishList Ninja to do one thing that neither a general loyalty suite nor a standard wishlist app is designed around: turn saved items into live, marketable buying intent.
Live buying-intent segmentation. WishList Ninja writes a real-time has_active_wishlist flag onto each shopper's Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend profile — and it is true only while they still have items saved. Alongside it we sync wishlist_count, wishlist_value and the shopper's top saved item. That lets you segment and email only the people who currently have live intent, instead of everyone who ever saved something once.
Seven automated flow triggers. WishList Ninja can fire flows for Added to Wishlist, Price Drop, On Sale, Low Stock, Back in Stock, Collection Saved, and New in a Saved Collection — so your ESP does the follow-up automatically.
Honest trade-offs. WishList Ninja is a paid app: $19–$249/month with a 30-day free trial and unlimited saves, and there is no free plan — so if a free wishlist is your priority, Magic Wishlist or Growave's free tier will suit you better. We are also brand-new in 2026, so we have far fewer reviews than Growave's 1,235; we'd rather say that plainly. Setup is a 1-click, no-code install with a roughly 12KB script.
Put simply: choose Magic Wishlist for a free, focused wishlist; choose Growave if you want loyalty and reviews bundled in; consider WishList Ninja if your goal is to segment and automate email around who has live wishlist intent right now.
Which is right for your store?
- You want a free, dedicated wishlist: Magic Wishlist offers a single free plan focused purely on wishlists (confirm current limits on its listing).
- You want loyalty, reviews and referrals alongside wishlist: Growave bundles them, with pricing that scales by monthly orders.
- You want to email based on live buying intent: WishList Ninja centres on the real-time
has_active_wishlistflag and 7 automated flows (paid, no free plan; disclosure: our app).
All figures here were taken from each app's Shopify App Store listing in July 2026 and can change. Verify pricing, ratings, plan limits and features on the live listings before you choose.