1. WishList Ninja — the email-first alternative

Disclosure: this is our app. From $19/month (30-day free trial, unlimited saves). Where Wishlist Plus stores the wishlist, WishList Ninja puts it to work: every save writes onto the shopper's Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend profile in real time — including a live has_active_wishlist flag — and fires 7 automated flow triggers. Best if you want the wishlist driving email revenue on a smaller budget. Full WishList Ninja vs Wishlist Plus comparison →

2. Growave — the all-in-one alternative

Loyalty, reviews, UGC and a wishlist in one app. Best if you want to replace several tools at once; less ideal if you only need the wishlist, since you pay suite prices for one module.

3. Swish (formerly Wishlist King) — the polished-widget alternative

A theme-native wishlist with a strong reputation. Note its price is pegged to your Shopify plan tier, so larger stores pay more for the same features.

4. Wishlist Hero — the budget alternative

The cheapest way in: a free tier for 500 saves a month, paid from $4. Lighter on the email side than the options above, but hard to beat on price.

How to choose

  • Switching to save money + do more email? → WishList Ninja
  • Want loyalty + reviews too? → Growave
  • Care most about the widget look? → Swish
  • Cheapest possible? → Wishlist Hero

Prices from public Shopify App Store listings, July 2026 — always check the live listing. Wishlist Plus is a product of Swym, not affiliated with WishList Ninja.