At-a-glance comparison (checked July 2026)
| App | Rating (reviews) | Free plan | Paid from | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WishList Ninja (ours) | New in 2026 | No — 30-day trial, unlimited saves | $19/mo | Email-driven wishlists |
| Wishlist Plus (Swym) | 4.8 (1,340) | No — 30-day trial | $29.99/mo | Enterprise / most-proven |
| Growave | 4.8 (1,174) | Yes — 200 orders/mo | $15/mo | Loyalty + reviews + wishlist |
| Wishlist Hero | 4.7 (366) | Yes — 500 adds/mo | $4/mo | Budget with email alerts |
| Wishlist – Wishify | 4.9 (197) | Yes — 100 items/mo | $5.99/mo | Guest wishlists, highest rated |
| Wishlist Guru | 4.8 (88) | Yes — 300 items/mo | $5.99/mo | Generous free tier |
| Smart Wishlist | 4.1 (58) | No — 60-day trial | $4.99/mo | Cheapest paid plan |
How we chose these apps
Shopify has no built-in wishlist, so the App Store has hundreds of options — most of them near-identical "save for later" buttons. To cut the list to seven genuinely useful picks, we weighed five things:
- Rating and review volume on the App Store — a proxy for how well the app holds up on real stores.
- Pricing and free tiers — what you actually get for free, and where the paid plans start.
- Email & automation depth — whether the wishlist just stores items or feeds your email platform (Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend), which is where a wishlist makes money.
- Storefront features — hearts, a drawer, a wishlist page, guest wishlists, sharing and cross-device sync.
- Store speed — a wishlist should not drag down your Core Web Vitals.
Every rating, review count and price below was checked against the app's live Shopify App Store listing in July 2026. Where we couldn't confirm a figure on the listing, we've left it out rather than guess.
1. WishList Ninja — best for email-driven wishlists
Pricing: $19–$249/mo · 30-day free trial · unlimited saves on every plan. Ours — see disclosure above.
WishList Ninja is built around one idea: a wishlist should power your email marketing, not just store items. Every paid plan syncs to Klaviyo, Mailchimp and Omnisend in real time, and it does two things we haven't seen another wishlist app advertise:
- A live
has_active_wishlistflag on every shopper's email profile — true only while their wishlist has items in it, alongside wishlist count, value and top saved item. That lets you build a segment of shoppers with live buying intent and email only them. - 7 ready-made flow triggers — Added to Wishlist, Price Drop, On Sale, Low Stock, Back in Stock, Collection Saved, and New in a Saved Collection — each fired into your email platform with the product, price and value attached.
The storefront side is complete too: heart buttons on product and collection cards, a slide-out drawer, a dedicated wishlist page, collection saving, share links and save-for-later on the cart — all on a storefront script under ~12KB, so page speed stays intact. It installs in one click through the theme editor with no code.
or try the interactive demo store.
Pros: the deepest email-platform integration on this list; the live intent flag; three ESPs on every plan; unlimited saves; lightweight. Cons: we're the newest app here (2026), so we don't yet have the review history or the "Built for Shopify" badge the veterans carry, and there's no permanent free plan — just the 30-day trial.
Best for: stores that run Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend and want the wishlist to drive automated, well-timed emails.
2. Wishlist Plus (Swym) — best for enterprise
Pricing: no free plan — 30-day free trial, then from $29.99/mo (per its App Store listing).
Wishlist Plus is the category veteran and, according to its Shopify App Store listing, the most-reviewed wishlist app here — 4.8 stars across 1,340 reviews, with a "Built for Shopify" badge. It's a mature, feature-rich wishlist: add and view lists, email and social sharing, automated reminders, price-drop and back-in-stock alerts, a conversion analytics dashboard, multi-language support and Shopify POS integration. Paid plans run Starter $29.99/mo (3,000 wishlist actions), Pro $59.99/mo and Premium $99.99/mo.
Pros: the largest install base and review count; deep, proven feature set; strong support and integrations. Cons: no permanent free plan for new stores (only a trial), and it's the priciest entry point on this list. See our full WishList Ninja vs Wishlist Plus comparison →
Best for: established or enterprise brands that want the safest, most-proven option and aren't fussed about price.
3. Growave — best all-in-one suite
Pricing: free up to 200 orders/mo, then Entry $15/mo, Growth $199/mo, Plus $499/mo (per its listing).
Growave (4.8 stars across 1,174 reviews, "Built for Shopify") bundles a wishlist together with loyalty points, product reviews, referrals and VIP tiers. Its free plan is genuinely useful if you want more than a wishlist, covering up to 200 orders a month across the whole suite.
Pros: four retention tools in one app; excellent rating; a real free tier. Cons: the wishlist is one module of a heavier platform, pricing scales on orders (not wishlist usage) and jumps steeply between tiers, and a broad suite can add more weight than a focused wishlist. See our full WishList Ninja vs Growave comparison →
Best for: stores that want loyalty, reviews and a wishlist from a single vendor.
4. Wishlist Hero — best free plan with email alerts
Pricing: free up to 500 wishlist additions/mo, then Silver $4/mo, Gold Plus $17/mo, Platinum $29/mo (per its listing).
Wishlist Hero (4.7 stars across 366 reviews) has one of the most generous free tiers in the category — and, unusually for a free plan, it includes price-drop and low-stock email reminders. Setup is code-free with theme integration, and it supports multi-currency, multi-language, wishlist additions from product pages, collections and quick views, plus email/social sharing and reporting.
Pros: real email reminders on the free plan; cheap paid tiers from $4; easy setup; well reviewed. Cons: the 500-additions monthly cap is easy to pass on a busy store, the free plan carries the app's branding, and the email side is lighter than a dedicated ESP-sync app. Read our full Wishlist Hero review →
Best for: smaller or budget-conscious stores that want a solid wishlist plus basic alerts without paying up front.
5. Wishify — highest rated / best for guest wishlists
Pricing: free up to 100 wishlist items/mo, then Professional $5.99/mo, Premium $12.99/mo, Advanced $29.99/mo (per its listing).
Wishlist – Wishify (by Zooomy) has the highest rating of the group on its listing — 4.9 stars across 197 reviews, with a "Built for Shopify" badge. Its standout is friction-free saving: guest wishlists with no login required, cross-device sync so shoppers pick up where they left off, add-to-cart straight from the wishlist, a fully customisable button/icon, automated email reminders and sharing by email, Facebook, WhatsApp or Twitter.
Pros: the highest rating here; strong guest-wishlist and cross-device experience; clean, customisable UI. Cons: the free plan's 100-items-per-month cap is tight for a busy catalogue, so most real stores move to paid quickly.
Best for: stores that want a polished, guest-friendly wishlist and don't need deep email automation.
6. Wishlist Guru — most generous free tier
Pricing: free up to 300 wishlist items/mo, then Basic $5.99/mo, Pro $12.99/mo, Premium $19.99/mo (per its listing).
Wishlist Guru (4.8 stars across 88 reviews, "Built for Shopify") sits between Wishlist Hero and Wishify on the free-tier ladder — its free plan allows up to 300 wishlist items a month, more than Wishify's 100. It focuses on guest wishlists and easy, customisable setup.
Pros: a middle-ground free cap that outlasts some rivals; strong rating; low paid entry price. Cons: a smaller review base than the veterans, and some features mentioned elsewhere online (such as Shopify Flow or API access) weren't stated on the listing we checked — confirm on the live listing if those matter to you.
Best for: stores that want a free wishlist with a bit more headroom before hitting a cap.
7. Smart Wishlist — cheapest paid plan
Pricing: no free plan — a single Standard plan at $4.99/mo with a 60-day free trial (per its listing).
Smart Wishlist (by Webmarked, 4.1 stars across 58 reviews) is the low-cost, no-frills option: one flat plan at $4.99/mo and an unusually long 60-day trial. Its listing highlights wishlist buttons on product, collection, search-result and cart pages, guest and logged-in support, unlimited wishlists, JavaScript and REST APIs for advanced needs, and a lightweight payload that doesn't leave code behind on uninstall.
Pros: the cheapest ongoing price here; a very long trial; developer-friendly APIs. Cons: the lowest rating of the group, some reviews cite support and reliability issues, and there's no permanent free tier.
Best for: budget stores that want a functional wishlist at the lowest flat monthly price and a long window to test it.
Also worth a look
A few other apps come up often and may suit specific needs, though we've kept the ranked list to the seven above:
- Swish (formerly Wishlist King) — a polished, theme-native wishlist whose price is tied to your Shopify plan tier.
- SE Wishlist Engine — a focused, well-rated wishlist with the core features done properly.
- Magic Wishlist — a newer free app that lists integrations with Klaviyo, Mailchimp and Omnisend on its App Store page (small review base for now).
How to choose the right one
- Want the wishlist to drive email revenue? → WishList Ninja (real-time Klaviyo/Mailchimp/Omnisend sync, the
has_active_wishlistflag, 7 flows). - Enterprise brand, want the most-proven option? → Wishlist Plus.
- Want loyalty + reviews + wishlist in one? → Growave.
- Want a free plan with basic email alerts? → Wishlist Hero.
- Care most about a guest-friendly, highest-rated widget? → Wishify.
- Want the most generous free tier? → Wishlist Guru.
- Cheapest flat paid price? → Smart Wishlist.
Whichever you pick, the biggest lever isn't the heart button — it's whether the wishlist feeds your email platform so you can bring shoppers back with a price-drop or back-in-stock email. That's the gap WishList Ninja was built to close.
Ratings, review counts and prices were taken from each app's public Shopify App Store listing in July 2026 and will drift over time — always check the live listing. Spot something out of date? Email [email protected] and we'll fix it.